New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Inconsistent placeholder styling in [over.built] #1233
Comments
The subclause also has a weird way of spelling "cv". |
Wait. I believe we agreed in #1139 that type placeholders such as "let Why do you believe this section should use \placeholders? (I agree this is slightly, but only slightly, different because we have an implied meta-iteration over the set of all matching types, so you can't just imagine a typedef there.) Agreed on the "cv" part. |
@jensmaurer: I see. To be clear, I'm not taking a position here whether the gadgets in question should be normal types or placeholder types. What I meant is that if they are placeholder types, then they should be formatted as I described. If we don't actually want to style them as placeholders at all, then we should of course apply a different resolution, but I hadn't thought of that. |
Uh, second thoughts about the "cv" part: We also have "VQ" in this section, meaning just a |
Yeah, absolutely. And that was somehow my motivation for this issue: It's not even internally consistent at the moment. I have no problem keeping most of this as is, I just think we can clean it up locally. As for the CV/VQ bit, maybe we can have some lower-case construction like "vqn" to mimic the usual styling for "cv"? I'm open to suggestions. |
Ok, let's go with \placeholder for the moment in this section. After all, the implied "for-all" quantification make the T's more like meta-variables than specific types. |
Yes, I agree, this isn't "one particular type |
Use \defn for definitions. Use \placeholder for meta-variables used in describing built-in candidate signatures. Fixes cplusplus#1233.
Use \defn for definitions. Use \placeholder for meta-variables used in describing built-in candidate signatures. Fixes #1233.
Subclause [over.built] uses type placeholders, which are styles as body text italics in the body text and as code italics in code. They should always be the latter, using
\tcode{\placeholder{...}}
in the body and\placeholder
or\placeholdernc
in codeblocks.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: