Closed
Description
Please delete
"If A and B are modifications of an atomic object M and A happens before (as defined below) B, then A shall precede B in the modification order of M, which is defined below. [ Note: This states that the modification orders must respect the “happens before” relationship. —end note ]"
from 1.10p6 [intro.multithread]. The normative sentence is redundant with 1.10p15. There seems to be a concensus among SG1 commentators that it's not worth preserving the note, which seems a bit shallow. It could also be added to p15 or integrated into p19.
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels
Activity
hboehm commentedon Jul 31, 2013
We did have one dissenting vote from Ville for keeping the note. The other 4 opinions seemed to weakly favor dropping it.
jensmaurer commentedon Nov 12, 2016
This is now 1.10.1 [intro.races] p4 and p13.
[intro.races] remove redundant constraint on modification order
[intro.races] remove redundant constraint on modification order
[intro.races] remove redundant constraint on modification order (#990)